It feels like a black swan event: last month, in GEICO Gen. Ins. Co. v. Harvey, No. 4D15-2724 (Fla. Ct. App. Jan. 4, 2017), a Florida appellate panel unanimously overturned a jury verdict, on the ground that the plaintiff’s bad faith claim was insufficient as a matter of law. A dissection of this rara avis can yield some insight into the limits of judicial tolerance for claims against insurers. The Fatal Accident On August 8, 2006, James Harvey and John Potts ... Keep Reading »
Eleventh Circuit Clarifies “Permanency” Requirement under Florida Bad Faith Statute
In Cadle v. GEICO Ins. Co., Case No. 15-11283 (11th Cir. Sept. 30, 2016), the Eleventh Circuit held that GEICO had not acted in bad faith when it failed to settle a claim after the insured did not provide any evidence of permanency during the cure period as is required by Florida law. With A Friend Like This… On July 2007, Catherine Cadle was rear-ended by Derek Friend, an underinsured motorist driving down I-95. Cadle had previously purchased insurance providing ... Keep Reading »