In Doctors Direct Ins., Inc. v. Beaute’ E’mergente, LLC, No. 1-14-2919 (Ill. App. Ct. June 22, 2015), an Illinois state appellate court recently affirmed that a medical malpractice liability insurer did not owe a duty to defend or indemnify its insured in an underlying class action lawsuit alleging violations of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (the “TCPA”) and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act (the “ICFA”), because there was no ... Keep Reading »
Wait A Minute, Mr. Postman: Tenth Circuit Applies Statutory-Violation Exclusion To Junk Fax Claims That Try To Skirt The TCPA
Enacted in 1991, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, 47 U.S.C. § 227 (TCPA), inaugurated the era of "junk fax" class actions, in which recipients of mass fax advertisements may pursue statutory damages of $500 per class member. Insurers responded by adding terms to liability policies that expressly exclude coverage for claims under the TCPA. But the dialectic of coverage litigation is ineluctable, and plaintiffs began asserting, in effect, that the TCPA was ... Keep Reading »
California Bans Use of Price Optimization
Yesterday California Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones became the latest voice in a growing chorus of state insurance regulators who condemn the use of "Price Optimization" as a mechanism for adjusting property-casualty insurance rates and pricing. In a Notice delivered to more than 750 P&C insurers, the Commissioner declared that "any use of Price Optimization in the ratemaking/pricing process or in a rating plan is unfairly discriminatory in violation of ... Keep Reading »
Connecticut Insurers Get a Day in Court to Resolve Regulatory Investigations
As Hillary Clinton can attest,some government investigations tend to drag on, and they create problems for their targets as long as they last. In late 2011, the targets of a lingering investigation by the Connecticut Insurance Department tried to lift the cloud over their business, by filing a declaratory judgment action in Superior Court. The trial court dismissed their suit, on the ground that the Department's proceedings had not yet run their course. But last ... Keep Reading »
Nutmeg, Sí, Palmetto, No!: Travelers Wins Both Sides of Insurer-vs.-Insurer Dispute
Although large or protracted losses can implicate more than one liability policy, sometimes only one insurer steps up to provide a defense. When that happens, the insurer can try any of several ways to recover its expenses from other carriers, including a declaratory judgment action, an action for equitable subrogation and a claim for contribution. But the law in this area is not uniform, as two recent cases illustrate. In Travelers Cas. & Surety Co. of America ... Keep Reading »